New Scholarship Condemning the Tobacco Master Settlement Agreement for Selling Out Indian Nations

Ryan D. Dreveskracht has posted his new paper, “Forfeiting Federalism: The Faustian Pact with Big Tobacco,” (PDF) just published in the Richmond Journal of Law and Public Interest.

Here is the abstract:

This article discusses the effects of the largest legal settlement in United States history: the so-called Master Settlement Agreement, or “MSA.” Part I discusses the settlement generally, and its intended effect on the U.S. tobacco market. Parts II through IV discuss the unintended consequences of the settlement. Specifically, Part II considers how states got into their current disarray, and how a perceived state windfall of billions of dollars ended up putting states on what by all accounts now appears to be very real risk of insolvency. Part III examines how the major tobacco companies are using the states’ dire financial condition to stifle tribal sovereignty and Indian industry. Part IV analyzes the federal government’s role in similar oppressive tactics. The concluding section suggests lessons that might be learned from the MSA.

 

OK Seeks New Tobacco Tax Deals with Tribes

Oklahoma officials are pushing to raise taxes on tribal tobacco sales to a level that could reduce or wipe out the competitive price advantage tribal smoke shops have enjoyed for decades.

Gov. Mary Fallin’s office, however, said the main goal in its negotiations on new tribal tobacco compacts is to make tobacco taxes more consistent in the state.

Article here.

Is the Indian Tobacco Market Dead?

Maybe. News articles from Indianz and the NYTs.