Coulter on the Apology Resolution

From the Indian Law Resource Center:

‘No Thanks’ to Congressional Apology

The Senate has just passed a resolution that apologizes to American Indians and other Native Americans for the wrongs done by citizens of this country. But a genuine apology means you won’t do it again, and this resolution does nothing at all to stop or correct the on-going wrongs that the federal government inflicts on Indian and Alaska Native nations.

Unfortunately our government still takes Indian land without paying for it, still refuses to account for the Indian money it holds, still violates its treaties with Indian nations without making amends, and still maintains a body of policy and law that is so discriminatory and racist that it should have been discarded generations ago.

To make a real apology, Congress needs to stop doing the things that it is apologizing to Indian nations and other Native peoples for. Americans generally do not know that the federal government continues to treat tribes and Alaska Native nations this way, and the evidence is that the public does not support or condone this mistreatment.

It is astonishing to most Americans that the federal government is still taking Indian land and resources – without due process of law and without fair market compensation, sometimes with no compensation at all. Of course, the Constitution says that Congress may not take anyone’s property except with due process of law and with fair
market compensation. But these rules are not applied to most land and resources owned by Indian tribes, and the government takes the land and resources at will. Obviously, this is wrong. Today, the government is trying to drive Western Shoshone Indians off their homelands in Nevada without a semblance of due process and with a payment of about 15 cents per acre. This is gold mining land, but that doesn’t make it alright to take it from its Indian owners. There are other present day cases. A few years ago, Congress confiscated part of the reservation that was shared by the Yurok Nation in California and turned it over to another tribe. Congress gloated at the time that it could do this without paying compensation because of Congress’ so-called “Plenary Power” over Indians and their property.

Continue reading

May 2009 Issue of Indigenous Notes

You can access the issue here. Articles include:

Center to discuss Principles of International Law for Multi-lateral Development Banks at UN Permanent Forum session


Attorney Leonardo Crippa will discuss MDB obligations during a Permanent Forum side event on May 26th.
OAS Photo

NEW YORK, New York – More than 2,000 indigenous leaders and representatives are expected to attend the eighth session of United Nations Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues, which convened on Monday, May 18 and runs through May 29. In addition to discussing the implementation of the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, the Forum will discuss the relationship between indigenous peoples and industrial corporations, and the need to promote corporate social responsibility. Center staff will be leading a workshop and discussion of our paper, Principles of International Law for Multi-lateral Development Banks on May 26th, 2009. (More…)
For more information on the Permanent Forum session and details of the side events, please visit the UN Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues website.

American States recommit to Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples

With help from indigenous activists and supporters, the Center achieved a small but very significant victory at last month’s Summit of the Americas. World leaders responded to the Center’s call for a renewed commitment to the American Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, and reaffirmed their commitment to respect indigenous peoples’ rights and promote the successful conclusion of the negotiations of the American Declaration. (More…)

Seeking justice, Latin indigenous leaders come to testify

Article by Rick Kearns, Indian Country Today

WASHINGTON, DC – Indigenous leaders from four Latin American countries came to Washington D.C. last month to assert that their respective governments are criminalizing their right to protest, preventing them from seeking justice. (More…)

Raul Ilaquiche of ECUARUNARI, a confederation of the Quechua peoples in Ecuador. Photo by Shayda Naficy.

Chain of extermination devastates Awa peoples in Colombia
Two more Awa leaders were killed this month by an unknown armed group. On May 10, Ademelio Servio Bisbicus and Marco Antonio Taicuz were shot to death in their homes. Bisbicus’ wife, Bertha Taicuz was wounded by the gunfire.

The attack came 6 weeks after the bodies of eight Awa Indians believed to have been murdered by FARC rebels in February were recovered in the indigenous territory of Tortugaña Telembí, Colombia. Two of the discovered bodies were pregnant women, both about 8 months pregnant when they were killed. (More…)


Mining and agri-business, including the cultivation of coca, have made the mountainous region that is home to the Awa, highly strategic in terms of military control. Photo courtesy of ONIC

Australia backs UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples; pressure builds for the United States, Canada and New Zealand to follow
In early April, the Australian government officially endorsed the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. By reversing its 2007 policy against the UN Declaration, Australia became the 144th country to adopt it. Now only three governments — the United States, Canada, and New Zealand — remain opposed to the UN Declaration, and many activists are encouraging these governments to join the rest of the world in its support of the rights of indigenous peoples. (More…)

Wilma Mankiller and other Indian leaders are urging President Obama to sign the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples.

Legislative efforts to end violence against Native Women
HELENA, Montana – The Montana State Legislature passed a resolution aimed at protecting Montana’s 27,529 American Indian and Alaska Native women living both on and off reservations. The resolution, introduced by Senator Carol Juneau (D-Browning), takes aim at the staggering national statistics confirming that Native women are far more likely to be raped or sexually assaulted than any other segment of the population. (More…)

US CONGRESS CONSIDER TRIBAL LAW and ORDER BILLMembers of the United States Senate have also responded to the horrific rates of violence against Native women by including special provisions on domestic and sexual violence in proposed legislation. (More…) Montana Senator Carol Juneau

Indians still await formal apology
Article by Gwen Florio
May 10, 2009

Twenty-one years ago, Congress apologized to Japanese Americans for interning them during World War II.

Sixteen years ago, Congress apologized for the “grave injustice” of overthrowing the Kingdom of Hawaii a century earlier.

Last year, the House – though not the Senate – apologized for “the fundamental injustice, cruelty, brutality and inhumanity of slavery and Jim Crow” segregation.

Ten days ago, Congress began – again – considering a resolution apologizing to Indian people for the injustices perpetrated upon them in the two centuries since a fledgling United States adopted a policy that stated, “The utmost good faith shall always be observed toward the Indian.” (Read the full article)


Bozeman Daily Chronicle: Ordinary Justice

http://bozemandailychronicle.com/articles/2009/04/11/news/20symposium.txt

From Bozeman Daily Chronicle

‘Ordinary justice’

Corporations, churches and even canasta clubs have more rights under U.S. law than American Indian tribes, and respect for human rights and basic fairness demand this must change, says a veteran Indian lawyer and rights advocate.

“All we want is ordinary justice,” Tim Coulter, a Potawatomi Indian and director of the Indian Law Resource Center in Helena, said Friday.

Coulter, who has battled for Indian rights for 40 years and has been honored by Columbia University for his work, spoke to a crowd of about 100 attending the American Indian Law and Resistance Symposium at Montana State University.

Congress has the power to take Indian tribal lands, seize millions of dollars from Indian accounts, take over tribal governments, and even wipe out the legal existence of tribes, Coulter said.

Injustice toward Indians is deeply imbedded in U.S. law, he said. The entire legal framework of U.S. Indian law is based upon the notion that the federal government possesses “plenary powers,” which aren’t written anywhere in the U.S. Constitution, but were invented by the U.S. Supreme Court, he said. That idea has been enforced by the government for the past 200 years.

Just as the black civil rights movement of the 1960s dismantled the racist “separate but equal” laws, Indians need to dismantle the racist framework of laws that deny their rights, he argued.

Continue reading

Indian Country Today: Seeking justice, Latin indigenous leaders come to testify

Originally printed at http://www.indiancountrytoday.com/home/content/42323512.html

WASHINGTON – Indigenous leaders from four Latin American countries came to Washington D.C. last month to assert that their respective governments are criminalizing their right to protest, preventing them from seeking justice.

In what they called an Indigenous Diplomatic Mission, representatives from Colombia, Peru, Ecuador and Chile presented testimony and documented evidence at the 134 period of sessions of the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights. With the assistance of American co-petitioners Indian Law Resource Center, they met with members of Congress, representatives of the Obama administration and the United Nations.

The outreach is part of a related movement toward the passage of an American Declaration of the Rights of Indigenous People.

But the main focus for the members of the Andean Coordinating Committee of Indigenous Organizations was getting their message to the IACHR and the international community. They say their protests are being criminalized and their people marginalized, even killed.

“We came here because we are defending our mother, Pachamama” said Miguel Palacin Quispe, chair of the CAOI and president of the National Confederation of Peruvian Communities Affected by Mining at hearings March 20.

“We are the victims of this criminalization and persecution. . for the thousands of instances of human rights violations in our territories we have requested this hearing,” Palacin Quispe said in his testimony before the IACHR, which acts as a consultative body to the Organization of American States and the Inter-American Court of Human Rights.

The Peruvian leader told commissioners about problems with the “extractive model” of business in Peru that has oil and other large companies engaging in “irrational exploitation,” causing “enormous damage and pollution” to indigenous territories.

“These new neighbors, the multinationals, have located their battles in our territories, and they have put us in a position where we have to defend ourselves.”

One of the Peruvian cases he brought before the commission was that of 29 indigenous activists who, after requesting a dialogue with mining company and government representatives who came to their territory without their consultation, were seized, held hostage and then tortured by the Peruvian National Police for three days in July of 2005.

For the most part, his presentation focused on more recent events.

“It is now known,” Palacin Quispe stated, “that 18 Colombian ethnicities are in danger of extinction and for them we mobilize, for them we protest and there is no mechanism for dealing with this. . we have become the objects of assassination, torture and imprisonment.”

“In many areas, they are preventing us from our constitutional right to mobilize and protest; and the strategy of the state is now to change laws. . so they criminalize dissidence, and in Chile, against the Mapuche, they use the anti-terrorist law. They also seek to privatize public land and along with this they are increasing the military presence in our territories.”

For Juan Edgardo Pai, an Awa leader from Colombia and one of the presenters at the hearing, the issue of militarization is very important.

“The militarization of our territory has brought terrible problems,” Pai stated in a phone interview with Indian Country Today after his testimony at the commission. He referred to the recent massacre of 27 Awa by the FARC and to other similar situations. “When there are armed conflicts there are many people displaced and many Awa have been killed by their anti-personnel mines.

“Our people are still trapped by some of those mines. The fumigations have also caused death; many of our children have been killed by the poisoning.”

Pai said the Colombian government has done nothing to help the displaced and suffering members of his community. He pointed to the recent effort to find some of the victims of the latest massacre as an example of Awa frustration with the government.

“I came here not only because of the massacre,” Pai recounted, “but for the politics of [Colombian President] Uribe who doesn’t respond to our needs and we have seen so many violations of our rights. . we told them about the paramilitaries threatening us also and they have done nothing.

“We have been forgotten by the Colombian government.”

While testimony at the hearings was tragic, there were some positive results to the visit, according to ILRC attorney Leonardo Crippa. He asserted that IACHR Commissioner Victor Abramovich, special rapporteur on the rights of indigenous peoples, was “quite interested in following up on the testimony. … and for a visit by him to Colombia along with the UN Special Rapporteur.”

“Another request we felt would get follow up was on our request for the commission to do a comparative analysis of the 11 Peruvian decrees adopted by the Peruvian government in 2007, known as the Forest Laws, with the American Convention on Human Rights to determine if this domestic legislation is in accordance with the international standards concerning human rights.”

Crippa pointed out that these same laws are being used to imprison indigenous activists who have lead protests in Peru and that issue, along with one of the situations in Colombia, are reasons that there should be a separate American Declaration of the Rights of Indigenous People.

“This regional declaration is needed to reflect the regional particularities of the region, especially those ones that were not reflected in the UN Declaration.”

In his meeting with Department of State officials, Palacin Quispe addressed the same theme.

“In that meeting we stated that if it’s true that the Obama administration signifies a change in U.S. policy, their relevant officials should participate in the next OAS discussion of the Project on the American Declaration of the Rights of Indigenous Peoples and to unblock the process so that this international instrument be finally adopted,” he wrote in a CAOI statement.

In a statement summarizing the hearings, the IACHR urged passage of the American Declaration, as well as decrying the situations that compelled the indigenous leaders to leave their own countries to seek justice.

“The IACHR condemns the murders of indigenous people carried out by private and state agents, and reiterates its concern over the frequency of social conflicts and acts of violence associated with disputes over the lands, territories and natural resources of indigenous peoples. These situations of conflict normally arise because the states do not adequately guarantee the protection of indigenous territories; nor do they guarantee indigenous peoples the right to participate in decisions concerning the activities that affect their rights.”

Indian Law Resource Center/NCAI to Host Lunch on Human Rights Violations Against South American Indians

More than 1,244 indigenous people have been assassinated in Colombia in the past five years.  This persecution is not unique to Colombia.  It is part of an alarming trend of human rights violations against indigenous peoples in South America.  Indigenous rights to life, land, equality, natural resources, self-determination, and religious freedom are under attack.  A strong American Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples will help prevent human rights violations in the Americas.

The Indian Law Resource Center and NCAI will host a brown bag lunch highlighting these human rights abuses:

March 19, 2009, 1:00-2:30pm

NCAI Conference Room

1301 Connecticut Ave., NW

Washington, D.C. 20036

For more information, see the Center’s website, http://www.indianlaw.org/node/391.

Jan. 2009 Issue of Indigenous Notes

Available here.

Third Indigenous Notes from Indian Law Resource Center

The third edition of “Indigenous Notes” from the Indian Law Resource Center is here.

Highlights:

ILRC Indigenous Notes No. 2

Here.

Headlines:

Inter-American Commission Hears Concerns over Indigenous Property Rights in Guatemala

WASHINGTON, D.C. – At Monday’s hearing of the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, representatives from the Indian Law Resource Center, Defensoria Q’eqchi’, and Maya communities told commissioners that establishing environmental protection areas in Guatemala without indigenous involvement violates human rights and environmental norms.

 

 

Plans to create the Sierra Santa Cruz protected area raised concerns that indigenous lands would be managed and controlled by a private institution on behalf of the Guatemalan government. The proposed project is one of many that seek to gain control of the land and resources which indigenous peoples have traditionally used and occupied in Guatemala.

 

At the hearing, Leonardo Crippa and William David, attorneys for the Indian Law Resource Center, were joined by four representatives of the Defensoría Q’eqchi’ – Arnoldo Yat Coc, Maria Santos Ax Tiul, Carlos Antonio Pop Ac, Alfredo Cacao Ical – and an indigenous leader, Elias Israel Pop Cucul, who represents 43 indigenous communities affected by the proposed protected area.

Continue reading