BLT on Cobell Oral Argument

From the BLT:

The U.S. Court of Appeals has issued nine opinions in the longstanding dispute between a group of American Indians and the Interior Department, and with yet another oral argument session today in the 13-year-old case you can expect at least one more opinion.

“Has it only been 13 years?” Chief Judge David Sentelle said today in court, where more than 100 people interested in the case gathered in the ceremonial courtroom to hear argument. “Some of us didn’t have gray hair when this started,” said D.C. solo practitioner Dennis Gingold, lead counsel for the plaintiffs. “Some of us had hair,” Judge Douglas Ginsburg responded.

The plaintiffs, including Elouise Cobell, a member of the Blackfeet tribe in Montana, allege the government owes billions of dollars for mismanaging a trust fund for the collection and dispersal of royalties from oil and gas companies, among others, that leased Indian land.

U.S. District Judge James Robertson last summer ordered the government to pay $455.6 million to the plaintiffs stemming from mismanagement of the Individual Indian Money trust. Both sides appealed the ruling. Robertson called a full, historical account “impossible” considering the cost of such a pursuit.

Court Awards Cobell Plaintiffs $455.6 Million

The final decision in Cobell is out — the Cobell plaintiffs are owed $455.6 million, according to Judge Robertson.

Here is the opinion.

There will be most certainly appeals to the D.C. Circuit and the Supreme Court by whomever does not prevail in the appellate court, but the trial court’s decision will likely be entitled to great weight on appeal.