New Scholarship on Allowing Tribes to Declare Bankruptcy

Here is a new student article, “Shooting Craps: How Denying Tribal Casinos Bankruptcy Relief Ensures that Everyone Loses and a New Rule to Provide Potential Chapter 11 Relief,” available on SSRN. It will be published in the Temple Law Review.

Here is the abstract:

In August 2012, the Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of California dismissed a Chapter 11 petition filed by the Santa Ysabel Resort and Casino finding that the casino was an ineligible debtor under the Bankruptcy Code. This Essay critiques the decision of the Bankruptcy Court and suggests that tribal casinos should not be summarily excluded from filing for bankruptcy. This is because the federal Indian Gaming and Regulatory Act dictates the corporate form of Indian casinos but potentially excludes them as eligible debtors.

Instead, this Essay proposes a new rule that courts should use when evaluating Tribal Casinos as semi-sovereign entities in Chapter 11 proceedings. Ultimately, this rule would allow certain tribal casinos to avail themselves of bankruptcy protection while still complying with federal law.

Bankruptcy Court Dismisses Santa Ysabel’s Bankruptcy Petition

Here are the materials:

DCT Minute Order

US Motion to Dismiss

San Diego County Motion to Dismiss

Santa Ysabel Omnibus Response to US & County Motions

US Reply

San Diego County Reply

Yavapai-Apache Nation Reply

Prior materials here and here and here and here.

Santa Ysabel Opposition to Motion to Dismiss Tribal Bankruptcy Petition

Here:

Santa Ysabel Opposition [with exhibits]

Santa Ysabel Opposition (Brief only)

The other pleadings are here.

News coverage here.

Update in Santa Ysabel Bankruptcy Case

There are now two motions to dismiss:

San Diego County Motion to Dismiss

Yavapai-Apache Motion to Dismiss

The petition and attachments are here.

Yavapai-Apache Motion to Dismiss Santa Ysabel Bankruptcy Petition

Here:

Yavapai-Apache Motion to Dismiss

The petition and attachments are here.

Santa Ysabel Resort and Casino Bankruptcy Filings

Here:

Santa Ysabel Resort and Casino Bankruptcy Petition

Omnibus Statement of Facts and Events