US v. Spotted Elk — Eighth Circuit Reverses Drug Conviction

The Eighth Circuit reversed one conviction in U.S. v. Spotted Elk, a case involving convictions in a large drug ring on the Oglala Sioux Tribe.

us-v-spotted-elk

Eighth Circuit: Oglala Sioux Tribe Waiver of Immunity

The Eighth Circuit held in Oglala Sioux Tribe v. C&W Enterprises that the tribe waived its immunity from suit in an enforcement action in state court despite the fact that the tribe had not expressly waived its immunity via the contract. Here are the materials:

appellant-brief

appellee-brief

oglala-v-c&w-ca8-opinion

Prisoner Religious Freedom Case in Eighth Circuit

In Fowler v. Crawford, the Eighth Circuit affirmed a district court dismissal of a claim that a prison’s denial of access to a sweat lodge to a Cherokee descendant violated the Religious Freedom Restoration Act. Here are the materials:

fowler-opening-brief

crawford-brief

fowler-reply-brief

fowler-v-crawford-ca8-opinion

Yankton Sioux v. US HHS — CA8 Decision

Here is the opinion, which was reported in Indianz yesterday.

Here are the briefs:

yankton-appellant-brief

us-appellee-brief

yankton-reply-brief

Nord v. Kelly — Tribal Court Jurisdiction over Tort Claim Arising on State Highway

Here, the Eighth Circuit affirmed the DCT opinion rejecting the jurisdiction of the Red Lake Band of Chippewa Indians tribal court over a tort claim arising out of an auto wreck on a state highway within the reservation. Judge Murphy concurred in a separate opinion, noting the distinction between the Red Lake Reservation, which has never been ceded, and the reservation of the Mandad, Hidatsa, and Arikara Nation, where the Strate case arose.

Here are the materials:

CA8 Opinion

Appellant Brief

Appellee Brief

Reply Brief

Hinsley v. Standing Rock C.P.S. (CA8) — Federal Tort Claims Act

Apparently, persons covered by the Federal Tort Claims Act retain immunity from suit by exercising their “discretion” to place children with alleged child molesters without warning the parents. Hinsely v. Standing Rock Child Protective Services (CA8)

Here are the briefs:

Hinsley Appellant Brief

Continue reading

Plains Commerce Bank v. Long Family Land & Cattle Co. Materials — Additional Update

Here is the entire set of Plains Commerce Bank v. Long Family Land and Cattle Co. materials, with the addition of two tribal court lower court orders:

ETA: Final SCOTUS decision has been added to this post as well.

Tribal Court Denial of Bank’s Motion for Summary Judgment

Continue reading

Commentary on the Plains Commerce Bank Cert Grant

The Supreme Court’s decision to grant certiorari in Plains Commerce Bank v. Long Family Land & Cattle Co. surprised me a great deal. It proves, I think, that Indian law scholars and practitioners cannot claim to predict how the Supreme Court is going to act (no big surprise there, given how few Indians or Indian lawyers have clerked for the Court), but I also think it shows that the so-called Supreme Court bar can miss one every now and then [SCOTUSBlog’s Petitions to Watch seemed to miss this one].

Continue reading

SCt Grants Cert in Plains Commerce Bank

The Supreme Court agreed to hear Plains Commerce Bank v. Long Family Land and Cattle Co. (No. 07-411). Here and here are our previous posts on this case that include the briefs and other materials. Here is the Court’s order. Opening briefs are due Feb. 14, response briefs due on March 12.

Plains Commerce Bank v. Long Family Land & Cattle Co. Materials — Update

Plains Commerce Bank’s cert petn reply brief is here: Reply Brief

All other materials are at our previous post.