Challenge to Interior Cancellation of Lease on Colorado River Indian Tribes Lands

Here are the early materials in Tuttle v. Jewell (D. D.C.):

Tuttle Complaint

Interior Motion to Transfer

Tuttle Response

Interior Reply

DCT Order Denying Motion to Transfer

Update in Pala Band Disenrollment Dispute

Here are the new materials:

13.05.09_SD AS-IA Brief re Pala dissenrollment appeals.

2013_04_29 Notice of Procedures

Brief.5.9.13.Final.Corrected

IBIA Order Dismissing Appeal 7.18.12

IBIA Petition for Reconsideration 8.12.12

Notice of Appeal Final 7.7.12

Order Denying Reconsideration.8.29.12

PALA Admin Records – INDEX Aguayo & Howard.5.10.13

RD Recommendation 6.7.12

Prior posts on the IBIA proceedings are here and here.

D.C. Circuit Decides “Old Section 81” Case

Here is the opinion in Quantum Entertainment Limited v. Department of the Interior:

Quantum Entertainment v Dept of Interior

Briefs are here.

Lower court materials are here.

D.C. Circuit Briefs in “Old Section 81” Appeal

Here are the briefs in Quantum Entertainment Inc. v. Dept. of Interior:

Quantum Opening Brief

Interior Answering Brief

Quantum Reply Brief

Lower court materials here.

Job Posting: Administrative Judge, Interior Board of Indian Appeals

Here.

Federal Court Decides “Old Section 81” Case — Quantum Enter. v. Interior

Here are the materials in Quantum Entertainment Ltd. v. Dept. of Interior (D. D.C.):

Quantum Entertainment Complaint

Exhibits

Interior Motion for Summary Judgment

Quantum Motion for Summary Judgment

DCT Order Affirming IBIA Decision

Shinnecock Wins IBIA Appeal — Become 565th Federally Recognized Tribe — UPDATED with IBIA Decision

Here is the IBIA decision: 38553324-Shinnecock-Decision

Here is the news article:

The Shinnecock Indian Nation received word Friday afternoon from its tribal attorneys that it is now officially the 565th Native American tribe to earn recognition from the U.S. government, according to Shinnecock Tribal Trustee Lance Gumbs.

Though neither the Interior Board of Indian Appeals or the Bureau of Indian Affairs has yet to formally announce the news, the Shinnecock Nation has cleared all the hurdles to federal recognition, the trustee said.

“The first day of October will live forever in the hearts and minds of the Shinnecock people,” Mr. Gumbs said in an phone interview Friday. “Everyone is just relieved and shedding tears for not only us who are here, but those who just missed it,” he said. He explained that some Shinnecock elders have died since July 19, when the tribe’s recognition application was originally expected to be finalized.

Continue reading

Materials in Shinnecock Federal Recognition Appeal before the IBIA

Here are a few selected briefs:

BIA Brief on Interested Parties

Shinnecock Answer Brief

CCGJ – Supple Brief – Merits

CCGJ Standing Brief

Montauk Reply

Shinnecock Nation Wins Procedural Victory in Federal Recognition Appeal

From tv, via Pechanga:

The Connecticut gaming group spearheading the challenge to the Shinnecock Indian Nation’s long-sought federal recognition was denied extra time to file additional paperwork in support of their argument in a ruling in early August.

The decision is a minor victory for the members of the Shinnecock Indian Nation, who have waited decades for federal recognition, and who want the legal challenge to their bid filed by the Connecticut Coalition for Gaming Jobs to be resolved as quickly as possible. Shinnecock Tribal Trustee Lance Gumbs had expressed frustration earlier this summer that the challenges had halted the tribe’s official federal recognition essentially on the eve of when they were slated to receive the designation.

“Obviously, their stuff was frivolous and they weren’t prepared,” Mr. Gumbs said of the CCGJ’s denied request. “It is what it is. They brought a frivolous suit and tried to build a case around it.”

The Interior Board of Indian Appeals, or IBIA, which is an administrative judicial department within the U.S. Department of the Interior charged with reviewing objections to federal recognition, denied the motion on August 4. If granted, the motion would have given CCGJ an additional month to file papers in support of its standing within the case against the Shinnecock Indian Nation. The board stated that CCGJ has already submitted arguments on its standing after initially filing 400 pages of arguments in July.

Continue reading

Opening Brief in Carcieri-Based Challenge to Santa Ynez Chumash Fee to Trust Decision

The case is Preservation of Los Olivos v. Pacific Regional Director, Bureau of Indian Affairs, in the IBIA.

Here: Appellants Opening Brief

News article here, via Pechanga.

Additional materials:

DCT Order Remanding to DOI (7/9/2008)