Federal Court Rejects South Dakota Effort to Quickly Prevail in Dispute with Flandreau over Liquor Regs and Casino Taxes

Here are the materials in Flandreau Santee Sioux Tribe v. Gerlach (D. S.D.);:

38 Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings

42 Flandreau Opposition

46 Reply

50 Flandreau Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings

51 Opposition to Flandreau Motion

54 Flandreau Reply

59 DCT Order

We posted the complaint here.

News Coverage of Goldwater (ICWA Litigation) Hearing

News coverage that confirms all accounts we received that this was a very difficult and discouraging hearing.

This hearing was on DOJ’s motion to dismiss the Goldwater ICWA litigation, which is contesting the constitutionality of ICWA. Relevant documents are here.

In response to questions we’ve been getting–this hearing was only on the government’s motion to dismiss. By the looks of it, the judge is not likely to dismiss the case at this point. Next up in the litigation is a fight over class certification, which the judge was delaying full briefing on until after the decision on the motion to dismiss. There will also be rulings on Navajo Nation and Gila River’s motions to intervene. Short answer to what the hearing likely means–this is looking like a long slog. We would really love to be wrong.

Garrett Epps on the Limits of the Constitution to Govern the US

Very interesting essay, frankly acknowledging the limitations of both the Constitution to govern and the Supreme Court to decide matters involving Indian country. 

From the Atlantic, here is “Can the Constitution Govern America’s Sprawling Empire?”

Kansas’ Challenge to Quapaw Trust Land Acquisition Dismissed

Here are the materials in State of Kansas ex rel. Schmidt v. National Indian Gaming Commission (D. Kan.):

43 US Motion to Dismiss

51 Quapaw Motion to Dismiss

56 Opposition to 51

60 Opposition to 43

68 Quapaw Reply

88 US Reply

91 DCT Order

Nooksack Tribe Countersues Proposed Disenrollees on Voting Rights

Here is the pleading from Belmont v. Roberts (Nooksack Tribal Court):

Def Answer and Countrclm to Pl Complaint

Ninth Circuit Denies En Banc Review in Pauma Compact Dispute, Issues Amended Order

Here is the amended order in Pauma Band of Luiseño Indians v. State of California.

En banc petitions here:

Cal En Banc Petition

Pauma En Banc Petition

San Juan County Ordered To Create New School Board Election Districts by January 28th, 2016

Link to press release from Navajo Nation DOJ here.

Previous posts about the case here.

Excerpt:

Leonard Gorman, Executive Director of the Navajo Nation Human Rights Commission, attended the status conference and said, “We are very pleased with how the hearing went yesterday. It was great that Judge Shelby agreed that Navajo voters in San Juan County should not have to tolerate violations of their constitutional rights through another election cycle. We are especially grateful to Judge Shelby for establishing a firm deadline for fixing the County’s illegal School Board election districts.”

Federal Court Issues Order in Penobscot River Dispute

Here is the opinion in Penobscot Nation v. Mills (D. Me.):

161 DCT Order

Briefs here.

Cert Petition (Yes, Another One) in Challenge to Crow Water Settlement

Here is the petition in Crow Allottees v. Dept. of Justice:

Crow Allottees Cert Petition

Question presented:

Can the water rights owned by individual Crow Indian allottees – which this Court in United States v. Powers, 305 U.S. 527 (1939) recognized as distinct individual rights, separate from water rights possessed by the Crow Tribe – be awarded to the Crow Tribe in negotiations between the United States, the tribe, and the State of Montana?
Further, do the Montana Courts have jurisdiction to decide these questions of federal law related to allottees’ rights?
Lower court materials: briefs, Mont SCT Opinion.
Related federal court materials here.

Published ICWA Notice Case out of California

Here is the opinion in In re D.C.:

D068146