“Is Texas Hold ‘Em a Game of Chance?”: Georgetown Law Journal

Here’s a new article in the Georgetown Law Journal asking whether poker is a game of chance or skill, with implications on the enforcement of the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act. Here is the abstract:

In 2006, Congress passed the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act (UIGEA), prohibiting the knowing receipt of funds for the purpose of unlawful gambling. The principal consequence of the UIGEA was the shutdown of the burgeoning online poker industry in the United States. Courts determine whether a game is prohibited gambling by asking whether skill or luck is the “dominant factor” in the game. We argue that courts’ conception of a dominant factor— whether chance swamps the effect of skill in playing a single hand of poker—is unduly narrow. We develop four alternative tests to distinguish the impact of skill and luck, and we test these predictions against a unique data set of thousands of hands of Texas Hold ‘Em poker played for sizable stakes online before the passage of the UIGEA. The results of each test indicate that skill is an important influence in determining outcomes in poker. Our tests provide a better framework for how courts should analyze the importance of skill in games, and our results suggest that courts should reconsider the legal status of poker.

View .pdf for full Article.

Now we’ll have to fend off the online gaming spammers inundating our comments….

Ninth Circuit Briefs in Evans v. Shoshone-Bannock Land Use Commission

Here:

Appellant Opening Brief

Appellee Answer Brief

Appellant Reply Brief

Lower court materials are here.

Opening Brief in Oklahoma Challenge to EPA Clean Air Act Determination re Tribal Authority

Here is the opening brief in Oklahoma Department of Environmental Quality v. EPA (D.C. Cir.):

Oklahoma DEQ Opening Brief

 

Tribal Amicus Brief on Constituitionality of Indian Child Welfare Act

Here:

12-399 bsacSeminoleTribeofFloridaetal

 

NARF/Casey Foundation Blog on Indian Child Welfare Developments

Welcome to ICWA INFO, described as:

In early 2013 Casey Family Programs partnered with the Native American Rights Fund to create an online resource that would focus solely on Indian child welfare issues.  Thus, began the ICWA INFO blog.  It was envisioned that this site would provide the public with information and timely updates about all things related to Indian child welfare and the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA).  This would include:

  • news about lawsuits related to ICWA in tribal, state, and federal courts,
  • related training and conferences,
  • legal analysis and research resources,
  • federal and state regulations,
  • information about relevant groups and agencies,
  • and job postings.

To see our most recent additions and edits, visit our home page.  To see past materials, you can use our search box or review materials by category, date posted, or topic from the links at the right.

We hope that you find this resource useful and we invite you to submit materials for this website at the contact page.

Highly recommended.

Materials in Denial of Yakama Motion to Dismiss Washington v. Yakama Tribal Court

Here:

DCT Order Denying Yakama Motion to Dismiss

Yakama Motion to Dismiss

Washington Opposition to Motion to Dismiss

Yakama Reply re Motion to Dismiss

PI materials here.

Idaho Argonaut on the Navajo Nation Supreme Court’s Visit to Idaho Law School

Here.

Minnesota American Indian Bar Association 2013 Annual CLE Conference

Initial details here. Always a very strong conference, as a glimpse at the roster of speakers demonstrates:

The Minnesota American Indian Bar Association and Minnesota CLE proudly present the 2013 Indian Law Conference, with special guest speakers:

  • Robert Tim Coulter, Executive Director, Indian Law Resource Center, Helena, Montana
  • Chief Judge Paul W. Day, Leech Lake Band of Ojibwe, Cass Lake
  • Judge John E. Jacobson, Shakopee Mdewakanton Sioux (Dakota) Community, Prior Lake
  • Chrissi Nimmo, Assistant Attorney General, Cherokee Nation, Tahlequah, Oklahoma
  • Judge John P. Smith, Minnesota Court of Appeals, Saint Paul
  • Megan E. Treuer, Executive Director, Regional Native Public Defense, Cass Lake
  • Mike Wiggins, Jr., Chairman, Bad River Band of the Lake Superior Tribe of Chippewa Indians, Odanah, Wisconsin

Plus, you won’t want to miss the complimentary reception sponsored by the Minnesota American Indian Bar Association in honor of Margaret (Peggy) S. Treuer, Member of the Leech Lake Band of Ojibwe and Chief Judge of the Bois Forte Band of Chippewa Tribal Court.

DOJ One-Pager on the Tribal Jurisdiction Provisions of the VAWA Reauthorization

Here:

VAWA 2013 and Tribal Jurisdiction Over Non-Indian Perpetrators of Domestic Violence (FINAL – 03-26-13)

Fifth Amendment Order in Criminal Case Arising on Fort Apache Reservation

Here are materials in United States v. Dehose (D. Ariz.):

DCT Order on Motion to Suppress

Dehose Motion to Suppress