Amended Ramah Findings and Conclusions

Download Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law here.

Link to previous coverage here.

Suit over Jackpile Uranium Mine Cleanup Proceeds

Here are the materials in Atlantic Richfield Co. v. United States (D. N.M.):

32 US Motion to Dismiss

34 Laguna Construction Co Motion to Dismiss

36 Laguna Pueblo Motion to Dismiss

46 AR Response to US Motion

47 AR Response to Pueblo Motion

48 AR Response to LCC Motion

63 LCC Reply

64 US Reply

67 Pueblo Reply

71 DCT Order Granting US Motion

73 DCT Order Partially Granting Pueblo Motion

75 DCT Order Denying LCC Motion

Complaint here.

Judge Approves Ramah Class Action Settlement

Ramah Final Approval Order Feb 24 2016

Ramah Final Approval Opinion Feb 24 2016

Dear Respected Tribal Leaders:

Earlier today, Judge Parker issued a final order approving the $940,000,000 Ramah class action settlement against the BIA.  We have attached the Order and Opinion. 

Congratulations to all of Indian Country!  It has been an honor and a privilege to be part of the team representing you and we look forward to implementing the settlement as quickly as possible.

As always, please feel free to contact us with any questions. 

Respectfully,

Lloyd, Don, and Lia

Federal Court Dismisses ICRA Habeas Petition for Failure to Exhaust

Here is the order in Steward v. Mescalero Apache Tribal Court (D. N.M.):

7 DCT Order

Federal Court Decides Quiet Title Act Matter

Here are the materials in Northern New Mexicans Protecting Land Water and Rights v. United States (D. N.M.):

22 US Motion to Dismiss

30 Response

31 Reply

33 DCT Order

Ramah Fairness Hearing Minutes

Hearing on Final Approval of Final Settlement Agreement (Doc. No. 1334) and on Application for Attorneys’ Fees and Costs (Doc. Nos. 1313 and 1335)

Things heat up on page 10 when attorneys call as a witness Professor Brian Fitzpatrick of Vanderbilt Law School to convince the court that 8.5% in attorney’s fees is fair when the Lodestar method would have awarded slightly less.  Ramah Class was awarded $940 million so that means $79 million will be fees.  Since class counsel spent just under 20,000 hours on the case the rate comes out to just under $4k/hour.  The court didn’t conduct its own Lodestar check.

Federal Court Affirms Navajo Nation May Sue Urban Outfitters under American Indian Arts and Crafts Act

Here are the materials in Navajo Nation v. Urban Outfitters (D. N.M.):

258 Navajo Response

287 Reply

606 DCT order

Previous posts here, here, and here.

Federal Court Dismisses Condemnation Action over Allotments in which Navajo Nation Has Property Interest

Here are the materials in Public Service Co. of New Mexico v. Approximately 15.49 Acres of Land in McKinley County (D. N.M.):

32 Navajo Motion to Dismiss

39 Response

45 Reply

101 DCT Order — Condemnation

Federal Court Dismisses Contract Action against New Mexico Pueblo Consortium

Back in April 2015….

Here are the materials in Corabi v. ENPIC Inc. (D. N.M.):

6 Motion to Dismiss

8 Opposition

10 Reply

13 DCT Order

Pueblo of Pojoaque v. New Mexico Preliminary Injunction Order (Gaming Dispute)

Previous filings posted here.

31 Memorandum Opinion and Order

32 Preliminary Injunction